Skip to content

Comparison

Timeliner vs Asana

General work management with timelines, portfolios and automations. Proofing covers images and PDFs, not video.

Honest comparison for a 5-editor video agency. We list what they do better, where they fall short for our ICP, and the real monthly cost.

Short answer

Asana is $54.95/mo for a 5-seat video team (Starter - 5 users × $10.99 (billed yearly; $13.49 billed monthly)). Timeliner is $89/mo (Studio - 5 seats, video review + pipeline included), with extra seats at $10/mo and free unlimited client and guest reviewers on every plan.

Pick Asana if…

If your agency already runs non-video work in Asana - strategy, paid media, web builds - and wants one company-wide system, keeping Asana for operations is sensible. Many teams do exactly that and run the video side, where review and client approval happen, in Timeliner.

Pick Timeliner if…

You need what Asana leaves out:

  • No video review: proofing annotates images and PDFs only, so there are no timecoded comments, no review player and no version compare for cuts.
  • Proofing and approvals require Advanced, at $24.99 per user per month billed yearly.
  • Clients join as guests inside Asana rather than reviewing from a branded link built for them.

Pricing

Real cost for a 5-seat video team

Posted prices, not list prices. The line item isn’t the whole stack - read the note below.

Asana$54.95/moStarter - 5 users × $10.99 (billed yearly; $13.49 billed monthly)
RecommendedTimeliner$89/moStudio - 5 seats, video review + pipeline included

Why the gap matters: Asana Starter is $54.95/mo for 5 users billed yearly ($67.45 billed monthly), but it has no video review - its proofing tool annotates images and PDFs, and only from Advanced ($24.99/user billed yearly, $124.95/mo for 5). Agencies pair it with a review tool such as Frame.io Pro ($75/mo), so the real stack is about $130/mo across two subscriptions and two places clients have to look. Timeliner Studio is $89/mo for 5 seats with review and the pipeline together, and extra seats are $10 each.

  • Timeliner Studio - $89/mo5 seats, 3TB, 1080p streaming. Frame-accurate review, the full production pipeline, the internal-then-client approval gate and branded client portals. Right for a small team replacing a review tool plus a PM tool.
  • Timeliner Agency - $199/mo10 seats, 8TB, 4K streaming. Everything in Studio plus payment tracking, approval-bottleneck analytics, client intake forms, the social calendar and AI captions, titles and tags. Right once you're billing clients and publishing.

Extra seats are $10/mo each (+250GB). Clients and guest reviewers are free and unlimited on every plan - they never count toward your seat limit. See all plans.

Plan by plan

Compare against any Timeliner plan

Starter - 5 users × $10.99 (billed yearly; $13.49 billed monthly). Switch tiers to see how seats, storage and features line up against what you’d actually pay.

AsanaTimeliner Studio
Monthly price$54.95/mo$89/mo
SeatsNo seat cap; seats added 1 at a time up to 5, then in blocks of 55 included (up to 10)
Extra seatNot published$10/mo (+250GB)
StorageNot published3TB
Streaming qualityNo video review - proofing is images and PDF (Advanced plan)1080p
Client & guest reviewersNot publishedFree & unlimited

What Timeliner Studio includes

  • Transcript & timecode commenting
  • Frame-accurate review & comments
  • Unlimited projects & versions
  • Client approvals via share links
  • Branded client portals
  • Internal supervisor approval
  • Kanban, list & brand views
  • Slack, WhatsApp & email alerts
  • Locked client downloads
  • Social scheduling for 1 brand
  • Priority WhatsApp · 8h response

Where Asana genuinely wins

We’re not pretending Asana is bad. These are real strengths - pick Asana if any of them are central to how you work.

  • Deep general work management: list, board, timeline and Gantt views, portfolios and goals across every team, not just video.
  • Unlimited automations from the Starter plan, plus forms with branching on Advanced.
  • Organisation-wide reporting dashboards and resource management at the higher tiers.
  • A large integration catalogue, including Salesforce, Tableau and Power BI on Advanced.
  • A low entry price for project management on its own, with unlimited free guests on Starter.

Where it falls short for a 5-editor video agency

  • No video review: proofing annotates images and PDFs only, so there are no timecoded comments, no review player and no version compare for cuts.
  • Proofing and approvals require Advanced, at $24.99 per user per month billed yearly.
  • Clients join as guests inside Asana rather than reviewing from a branded link built for them.
  • No Premiere Pro or After Effects integration - Asana's Adobe panel covers Photoshop, Illustrator and InDesign.
  • No social publishing, and no client invoicing or payment tracking.
  • You build and maintain the video workflow yourself; nothing ships shaped for editor → supervisor → client.
The headache you’ll feelAsana runs the task list, but the cut lives somewhere else. Notes arrive in Frame.io or an email, someone copies them into an Asana subtask, and the editor checks the wrong place to see what changed. Clients are guests in a work-management tool they didn't choose, and the approval that matters - the client saying yes to version 3 - never lands on the task.

Feature by feature

Feature Comparison

Supported Supported natively Partial or add-on Partial or via add-on Not available Not available

FeatureTimelinerAsana
Project & Task ManagementSupportedSupported
Custom Task WorkflowsSupportedSupported
Workflow AutomationsSupportedSupported
Custom FieldsPartial or add-onSupported
Third-Party IntegrationsPartial or add-onSupported
Workload & Capacity PlanningSupportedPartial or add-on
Timestamped Video CommentsSupportedNot available
Side-by-Side Version ComparisonSupportedNot available
Drawing AnnotationsSupportedPartial or add-on
Native Adobe IntegrationPartial or add-onPartial or add-on
Internal-then-Client Review GateSupportedPartial or add-on
Client Approval Portal (No Login)SupportedPartial or add-on
Branded Client Portal (Logo + Colors)SupportedNot available
Team Analytics & KPIsSupportedPartial or add-on
Payment Tracking & Pricing TemplatesSupportedNot available
Social Publishing & SchedulingSupportedNot available

Frequently Asked Questions

Not frame by frame. Asana's proofing tool, on the Advanced plan and up, places pinned comments on images and PDFs and turns each one into a subtask; it has no video player with timecoded comments or version compare. Video agencies on Asana usually review in a separate tool such as Frame.io. Timeliner has frame-accurate review, drawings, voice notes and version compare built into the same task.

Asana Starter is 5 × $10.99 = $54.95/mo billed yearly, or $67.45/mo billed monthly. Add Frame.io Pro ($75/mo) for video review and the stack is about $130/mo across two subscriptions. Timeliner Studio is $89/mo for 5 seats with frame-accurate review, the production pipeline, the internal-then-client approval gate and branded client portals in one tool.

In Asana, clients are invited as guests into your workspace. In Timeliner, clients open a branded portal from a link with no account, comment on the frame and approve from their phone, and they only see the versions you sent them. Client and guest reviewers are free on every Timeliner plan.

Yes, and many agencies do: Asana for company-wide operations, Timeliner for the video pipeline where review, client approval and publishing happen. When you are ready to move video projects over, the migration page explains what moves and what it costs.

When Asana is the right call

If your agency already runs non-video work in Asana - strategy, paid media, web builds - and wants one company-wide system, keeping Asana for operations is sensible. Many teams do exactly that and run the video side, where review and client approval happen, in Timeliner.

Run your agency in one place.

Briefs, edits, approvals, posting and invoices in one place clients actually use.

No charge until day 15

Full walkthrough with Noam · 15 min